Benefits
Hot flash frequency and severity
A meta-analysis of 17 placebo-controlled trials found that soy isoflavones (median 54 mg a day) cut hot flash frequency by about 21% and severity by about 26%, with more effect from products richer in genistein. Other studies show mixed results: a 2013 review of 43 trials found no conclusive evidence for phytoestrogens overall and noted a strong placebo effect, and a 2-year trial of 200 mg a day did not relieve symptoms.
Bone density after menopause
In a 2-year trial in 389 women with low bone mass, 54 mg a day of genistein increased spine and hip bone density while the placebo group lost bone. A meta-analysis of extract trials found about 2.4% higher spine density but no hip effect. Other trials show mixed results: two US trials of 80 to 200 mg a day of soy isoflavone tablets for 2 to 3 years found no protection against bone loss. Fractures were not studied.
Total and LDL cholesterol
A meta-analysis of 11 randomized trials found that soy isoflavones lowered total cholesterol by about 1.8% and LDL cholesterol by about 3.6%, with larger drops in people with high cholesterol. HDL cholesterol and triglycerides did not change. The effect is small next to diet changes or medication.
Mechanism of action
Weak estrogen-like activity
Genistein and daidzein bind estrogen receptors, much more weakly than the body's own estradiol. This is the proposed reason for effects on hot flashes and bone, and the reason women with hormone-sensitive conditions are advised to be cautious.
Equol production by gut bacteria
Some people's gut bacteria convert daidzein into equol, a more active compound. Whether a person makes equol is one proposed reason responses to soy isoflavones vary.
Bone turnover
In the genistein trial, genistein lowered urine markers of bone breakdown and raised a blood marker of bone formation compared with placebo, without thickening the uterine lining over 2 years.
Clinical trials
Systematic review and meta-analysis of double-blind randomized placebo-controlled trials of extracted or synthesized soy isoflavones (Taku et al. 2012, Menopause)
19 trials in perimenopausal and postmenopausal women; 13 trials pooled for frequency and 9 for severity.
Isoflavones (median 54 mg a day for 6 weeks to 12 months) reduced hot flash frequency by 20.6% and severity by 26.2% compared with placebo. Heterogeneity between trials was high, and products with more than 18.8 mg of genistein worked about twice as well.
Randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial of 54 mg a day of genistein for 24 months; both groups also took calcium and vitamin D (Marini et al. 2007, Ann Intern Med)
389 osteopenic postmenopausal women at 3 university centers in Italy.
Spine bone density rose 0.049 g/cm2 with genistein and fell 0.053 g/cm2 with placebo (difference 0.10 g/cm2); femoral neck density differed by 0.062 g/cm2. Bone breakdown markers fell. Stomach side effects were more common with genistein (19% vs 8%). Fractures were not measured.
3-year randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial of 80 or 120 mg a day of soy isoflavone tablets, with calcium and vitamin D in all groups (Alekel et al. 2010, Am J Clin Nutr)
224 healthy postmenopausal women aged about 46 to 65 without osteoporosis.
No treatment effect on spine, hip, femoral neck or whole-body bone density; bone density fell in all groups. After statistical adjustment, 120 mg a day showed a small protective effect at the femoral neck only.
Randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial of 200 mg a day of soy isoflavone tablets for 2 years (Levis et al. 2011, Arch Intern Med)
248 women aged 45 to 60 within 5 years of menopause.
No difference from placebo in bone loss at the spine, hip or femoral neck. Hot flashes and constipation were more common in the soy group, and other outcomes did not differ.